Compare and purchase the best car insurance rates in Barrie.
Car insurance in Barrie can be influenced by factors like winter driving conditions, commuter traffic, and local claims trends. Surex helps Barrie drivers compare coverage options from leading insurers and find protection that fits their needs and budget.
Get free and accurate quotes in minutes, and speak with a licensed advisor who understands Ontario coverage requirements.
New Ontario auto insurance changes take effect July 1, 2026
What makes car insurance different in Barrie?
While all Ontario drivers must carry certain mandatory coverages, local driving conditions and claims trends in Barrie can still affect coverage needs and insurance costs. Understanding these factors can help you better compare quotes and coverage options.
Key factors that can affect car insurance coverage and pricing in Barrie include:
- Winter driving conditions: Snow, ice, and reduced visibility during Ontario winters can increase the risk of accidents and weather-related claims.
- Commuting and traffic patterns: Regular travel within Simcoe County and along Highway 400 can increase time spent on the road and exposure to potential accidents.
- Repair and claims costs: Local repair expenses and regional claims trends can influence how insurers price coverage.
- Population growth and road usage: As Barrie continues to grow, increased traffic volume can contribute to changing driving risks and insurance considerations.
- Ontario insurance requirements: Drivers must carry mandatory minimum coverages required by the province.
Connect with a local Surex insurance advisor to review your options and find coverage that fits your needs and budget.
Why Barrie drivers use Surex
Surex helps Barrie drivers compare quotes from multiple insurers in one place, making it easier to review coverage options and make informed decisions. Our licensed advisors understand Ontario insurance requirements and provide personalized guidance before and after you choose your policy.
Get the best rates from Canada’s top insurance providers
Average car insurance prices in Canadian cities 2026
We reviewed thousands of car insurance quotes and found out how much drivers in Barrie pay on average for their premium. See how your city compares.
City |
Annual Premium |
Monthly Premium |
|---|---|---|
Barrie |
$2212.00 |
$184.33 |
Brampton |
$3300.00 |
$275.00 |
Brantford |
$2109.00 |
$175.75 |
Burlington |
$2082.00 |
$173.50 |
Calgary |
$2007.00 |
$167.25 |
Edmonton |
$2099.00 |
$174.92 |
Guelph |
$1539.00 |
$128.25 |
Halifax |
$1267.00 |
$105.58 |
Hamilton |
$2047.00 |
$170.58 |
Kingston |
$1928.00 |
$160.67 |
Kitchener |
$1851.00 |
$154.25 |
Lethbridge |
$1596.00 |
$133.00 |
London |
$2317.00 |
$193.08 |
Markham |
$2398.00 |
$199.83 |
Mississauga |
$2837.00 |
$236.42 |
Moncton |
$1596.00 |
$133.00 |
Oakville |
$2540.00 |
$211.67 |
Orillia |
$1680.00 |
$140.00 |
Oshawa |
$2250.00 |
$187.50 |
Ottawa |
$2115.00 |
$176.25 |
Peterborough |
$1739.00 |
$144.92 |
Red Deer |
$1825.00 |
$152.08 |
Sault Ste. Marie |
$1964.00 |
$163.67 |
Scarborough |
$2721.00 |
$226.75 |
Thunder Bay |
$1850.00 |
$154.17 |
Toronto |
$2537.00 |
$211.42 |
Windsor |
$1759.00 |
$146.58 |
Average prices are based on Surex quotes in the past 12 months for drivers with one vehicle and no claims. Updated April 2026.
What impacts car insurance rates in Barrie?
Car insurance premiums in Barrie can vary depending on factors like your driving history, vehicle type, coverage choices,
and daily commuting patterns. Winter driving conditions, traffic volume, and local claims trends can also affect pricing.
These examples are intended to demonstrate how rates may differ between drivers.
Types of coverage we provide
You can extend your car insurance coverage to protect you while driving a rental vehicle, up to a certain limit.
Protects you or a family member if injured or killed in an accident caused by an uninsured/under-insured motorist.
Provides coverage to repair/replace your car if it's damaged in an at-fault accident, hit and run, or with an uninsured driver.
Typically covers fire, hail, theft, collision with an animal, vandalism, and falling objects, among others. (subject to a deductible).
In the event of a "total loss", this coverage will protect you from depreciation. You’ll be entitled to the original price you paid/current sale price.
Windows are included in comprehensive*, however, you have the option to remove this coverage to lower your premium. (*Not included in Alberta.)
Allows one 'free' at-fault accident, meaning your rates will not increase on your first accident if you remain with the same provider.
This allows for the protection of your “claims-free discount” in the event of your first claim.
How Surex supports local drivers
Surex connects Barrie drivers with licensed insurance advisors who understand Ontario insurance requirements and local driving conditions. They can help you compare providers, review coverage options, and answer your questions about policy changes or claims.
Whether you’re comparing quotes for the first time or reviewing your current policy, a Surex advisor can help you better understand your options and choose coverage with confidence.
See what drivers in Barrie and across Ontario are saying about Surex
Find out how Surex helps local drivers compare coverage, get answers to their questions, and choose the right policy for their needs.
Lisa Clark helped me with my insurance! It was so easy and fast to get a quote and set it up. Super appreciative of Lisa and her hard work right when I needed it most. Got approved for insurance and am now driving my first car :)
10/10 service all the way around
Can't recommend Surex enough! Matthew Gill in SW Ontario has always been wonderful. I have been with Surex for some time now and have always received impeccable, friendly, professional, and quick service. Buying a car is a pain, and getting it insured can be a tortuous experience. Thanks Matthew for making so easy for us!
Right from the start I have had a very pleasant experience with Surex. In particular dealing with Miguel Pavon, who went the extra mile to ensure I was well taken care of and all my concerns were resolved. Miguel is efficient and kind. He was timely in the process of securing both my home and auto insurance. I highly recommend him snd hope he is appreciated as one of your team members.
Thanks
Susan Korpela
How Barrie drivers can save on car insurance
Barrie drivers can lower their car insurance costs by comparing quotes regularly, bundling policies, maintaining a clean driving record, and reviewing deductible options. Choosing a vehicle with lower repair costs and asking about available discounts can also help reduce your premium.
A licensed Surex advisor can help you compare quotes from multiple insurers, identify savings opportunities, and review coverage that fits your needs and budget.
Car Insurance in Barrie - FAQs
Car insurance in Barrie costs approximately $2,212 per year, or about $184.33 per month, on average. However, premiums can vary widely based on factors like your driving history, vehicle type, and coverage choices.
Car insurance rates in Barrie are affected by local factors like winter driving conditions, commuting patterns, and claims trends. Insurers also consider your vehicle type, coverage choices, and claims history when calculating your premium.
Drivers in Ontario are required to carry at least $200,000 in third-party liability coverage, along with accident benefits, direct compensation property damage (DCPD), and uninsured automobile coverage. These mandatory coverages provide essential financial protection in the event of an accident
You can lower your insurance costs in Ontario by maintaining a clean driving record, bundling policies, increasing your deductible, and comparing quotes from different insurers. A licensed insurance advisor can also help you identify savings opportunities and find coverage that fits your needs and budget.
Yes, winter weather can affect insurance premiums in Barrie by increasing the risk of accidents and weather-related claims. Snow, ice, freezing rain, and reduced visibility can all contribute to higher claim frequency during the winter months
Learn more about car insurance in Ontario
Car insurance and coverage needs can vary depending on your driving habits, vehicle, and where you live in Ontario. Whether you’re moving or reviewing your current policy, explore broader car insurance information for the province.
Compare 10+ quotes and
speak to a dedicated advisor
Underwriting Specialist
